making a difference
Precision Illuminated: Navigating Enterprise Value Amid Buyer Scrutiny
June 10, 2025 | Report
By Matt Hinkamp, Ryan Tierny
Facing unprecedented buyer scrutiny, sellers must demonstrate tangible operational improvements and rigorous deal readiness to maximize valuations.
Buyers today demand proof of performance, not just potential. For mid-market companies preparing for sale, operational precision and strategic narrative alignment have become the deciding factors between deal friction and premium outcomes.
​
A wave of deferred exits is converging with record PE dry powder—over $2.6 trillion globally—flooding the market with sellers and intensifying buyer scrutiny. Gone are the days when multiple expansion or favorable debt terms alone could boost valuations. Sophisticated buyers now prioritize diligence-ready businesses with verifiable operational improvements and aligned strategic messaging.
​
This shift has rewritten the sell-side playbook. Companies seeking premium outcomes must begin shaping the deal long before they engage buyers. Readiness isn’t a final-stage checklist—it’s the foundation of a successful transaction.
​
[Placeholder for visual showing multi-year PE dry powder levels alongside the increase in PE portfolio company hold periods and the backlog of deferred exits. This chart should establish the urgency created by excess capital meeting a saturated exit pipeline.]
Operational credibility, built through measurable results and proven execution, directly drives buyer trust and valuation premiums.
Amplifying Value in Rough Waters
As more sellers enter the market, differentiation depends on operational credibility. Buyers no longer accept optimistic projections without supporting execution. They want to see functioning processes, cost discipline, and growth capacity in action.
​
[Placeholder for quote from a private equity deal partner highlighting that buyers prioritize execution over aspiration—especially when operational discipline is already evident in the numbers and processes.]
​
High-impact improvements—such as in engineering, supply chain, or labor—can materially shift EBITDA when supported by targeted interventions. These are often in areas like engineering productivity, supply chain cost control, or labor efficiency. These operational enhancements improve EBITDA and sharpen the business's valuation narrative.​
Case in Focus: Driving EBITDA
A PE-backed industrial manufacturer, preparing for sale amid significant cost overruns, implemented targeted changes with Keystone's support. Project-level controls, labor optimization, and quoting accuracy drove improvements: engineering efficiency rose by 30%, material costs fell by up to 45%, and 80% of projects outperformed budget by double-digit margins. EBITDA ultimately exceeded targets by nearly 40%—results that strengthened buyer trust and signaled operational maturity.
​
[Placeholder for bar or waterfall chart breaking down EBITDA impact by intervention: quoting accuracy, project-level controls, labor management, etc. This should visually represent how each lever contributed to performance uplift.]
​
But executing change isn’t enough. In today’s environment, sellers must also demonstrate that value through clear, credible messaging.
Aligning strategic messaging with demonstrated operational performance is essential to accelerating buyer conviction and minimizing diligence friction.
Harboring Trust with Unified Narratives
Valuation depends as much on perception as performance. Buyers evaluate not only what a company has achieved, but how coherently it presents that progress.
​
Developing a unified equity story across CIMs, management presentations, and market studies is essential to buyer conviction. This includes refining CIMs, preparing management presentations, and ensuring market studies reinforce a cohesive and credible message.
​
This strategic alignment accelerates buyer conviction and reduces diligence friction. A fragmented story invites skepticism; a cohesive one commands attention​
Case in Focus: Amplifying Value Perception
In another case, a high-growth automotive services provider nearing exit sought to maintain momentum while managing sell-side complexity. Keystone helped align market messaging and coordinated with advisors, enabling the company to complete three acquisitions pre-sale while advancing 20 strategic initiatives. EBITDA rose by 20%, margins improved by 300 basis points, and the leadership team was enabled to focus on execution—not deal administration.
​
[Placeholder for pre/post KPI chart showing EBITDA, margin %, initiatives completed, and acquisitions executed before and after Keystone’s support. This visual should emphasize how operational progress was sustained during the transaction process.]
​
Yet even the most compelling story falters under scrutiny if diligence isn’t tightly managed.
Disciplined diligence preparation secures buyer confidence, prevents valuation erosion, and ensures a successful transaction close.
Establishing Solid Ground Through Diligence
Diligence is where deals succeed—or stall. In a high-volume market, buyers move quickly but expect precision. Gaps in documentation, inconsistent metrics, or delays in response can erode trust and valuation.
​
Coordinated diligence preparation across finance, operations, and strategy ensures materials align with the QoE narrative and minimize disruption to management to help sellers prepare the full suite of materials buyers expect, from operational data to financials to strategic documentation. By aligning this information with the QoE narrative and managing information flow, Keystone allows management to remain focused on running the business.
​
By professionalizing the process, sellers avoid disruption and enhance buyer confidence. In a competitive bidding environment, confidence converts to better terms, faster closing, and reduced execution risk.
​
[Placeholder for 2-column table comparing Common Diligence Pitfalls vs. Structured Preparation Outcomes. This visual should reinforce how readiness prevents the typical causes of deal friction, retrading, or slowdowns.]
​
Buyers rely on clean, timely, and aligned diligence materials to build conviction and avoid last-minute surprises. When information is inconsistent, delayed, or difficult to verify, it raises red flags that slow momentum or reduce bid confidence. In a competitive bidding environment, confidence converts to better terms, faster closing, and reduced execution risk.​
From Preparation to Positioning Power
The most successful exits are engineered. They don’t rely on last-minute preparation or presentation polish. Instead, they reflect months of disciplined execution, narrative clarity, and strategic coordination.
​
This is the readiness advantage. It builds value before the buyer arrives. It creates the conditions for stronger outcomes. And it transforms preparation from a back-office task into a front-line differentiator.
​
In today’s market, readiness isn’t just a phase. It’s the deal.
​
[Placeholder for flywheel visual illustrating the interconnected cycle of readiness: Operational Execution → Narrative Alignment → Diligence Precision → Buyer Confidence → Valuation Realization. This visual should synthesize the full strategic logic of the article into a conceptual takeaway.]